Following the appointment of the new Cabinet, the Forest Sector now reports to the ministère des Ressources naturelles et des Forêts, while the Wildlife and Parks Sectors report to the ministère de l'Environnement, de la Lutte aux changements climatiques, de la Faune et des Parcs. Adjustments will be made to the website over time.

Back to publications

The “sweet spot” for maple syrup production proposed by Rapp et al. (2019) is not that sweet

Summary

Published in Forest Ecology and Management 458: 117662. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.foreco.2019.117662

In their paper recently published in FEM (“Finding the sweet spot: Shifting climate optima for maple syrup production in North America”), Rapp et al. (2019) suggest that there is a marked “sweet spot” for maple syrup production (i.e., a climatic optimum associated with much higher yield) centered around the 43rd parallel. They also project that this climatic optimum could move 400 km northward in the future, as climate change drives temperatures to increase. As a result of this shift, they also predict that maple syrup production in the northeastern United States will rapidly decline in the next decades, and that the whole maple syrup industry could be at risk in several states. At the same time, they predict that maple syrup production will markedly increase in southeastern Canada, especially in the province of Quebec. Here we show that the predictive model built and used by Rapp et al. (2019) to project future maple syrup yield from climate scenarios is biased and presents several major flaws. We then demonstrate, using a data set of historical data many orders of magnitude larger than the one used by Rapp et al. (2019), that maple syrup yield is remarkably stable across a broad latitudinal and temperature gradient and therefore, that no climate optimum exists. This exercise leads us to conclude that the collapse of the U.S. maple syrup industry predicted by Rapp et al. (2019) is not based on solid evidence.

Sector(s): 

Forests

Categorie(s): 

Scientific Article

Theme(s): 

Ecosystems and Environment, Forestry Research, Forests

Departmental author(s): 

Duchesne, Louis, Houle, Daniel

Author(s)

HOULE, Daniel, Louis DUCHESNE

Year of publication :

2020

Format :

PDF available upon request

ISSN

0378-1127

Keywords :

forestry research scientific article, sirop d’érable, changements climatiques, rendement, nord-est de l’Amérique du Nord, écosystèmes et environnement, production, article scientifique de la recherche forestière, ecosystems and environment, maple syrup, yield, climate change, North-Eastern America

Partagez